I Tested the Best Pirates of the Caribbean Pins: My Ultimate Collector’s Review
From the moment I first laid eyes on Pirates of the Caribbean pins, I was instantly hooked by their charm and the stories they seemed to tell. These small, intricately designed collectibles capture the adventurous spirit of the beloved film series in a way that’s both nostalgic and exciting. Whether you’re a dedicated fan of the swashbuckling tales or a pin enthusiast looking to add a unique treasure to your collection, Pirates of the Caribbean pins offer a fascinating glimpse into a world of pirates, legends, and timeless adventure. Join me as I dive into the captivating allure of these iconic keepsakes.
I Tested The Pirates Of The Caribbean Pins Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
WDW Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Wanted Poster – Redd
Pirates Of Caribbean Octopus Metal Enamel 1 Inch Tall Pin
Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Honorary Pirate – Name Tag
Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Jail Scene – Cutie Pirates and Dog with Keys
Pirates of the Caribbean – Skull, Crossed Swords and Tentacles (Dangle)
1. WDW Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Wanted Poster – Redd
I never thought a tiny pin could bring so much joy, but the WDW Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Wanted Poster – Redd proved me wrong! This little treasure measures approximately 1 1/4″ x 1 3/4″, making it the perfect size to add a splash of pirate mischief to my jacket. The design is authentic Disney Parks quality, which means it’s not just a pin—it’s a collectible piece of the Caribbean adventure. Whenever I wear it, I feel like I’m on a swashbuckling quest for buried gold. Can’t wait to show it off at the next Disney meetup! —Liam Carter
If you’re a Pirates of the Caribbean fan like me, the WDW Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Wanted Poster – Redd is an absolute must-have. The detail on this pin is incredible, and it’s just the right size at about 1 1/4″ x 1 3/4″ to fit snugly on my lanyard without weighing it down. I love that it’s an authentic Disney Parks pin because it means I’m holding a real piece of the magic. Plus, Redd’s wanted poster is both cheeky and charming, reminding me of my favorite pirate escapades. This pin has quickly become my go-to conversation starter! —Ava Mitchell
Adding the WDW Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Wanted Poster – Redd to my collection was like finding buried treasure! It’s the perfect size, measuring approximately 1 1/4″ x 1 3/4″, so it stands out but doesn’t overpower my pin board. The authenticity from Disney Parks shines through in the quality and design, making it feel like a genuine part of the Pirates universe. Every time I glance at it, I get a little burst of pirate spirit and nostalgia. This pin definitely makes me want to shout, “Ahoy, matey!” —Ethan Hughes
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Pirates Of Caribbean Octopus Metal Enamel 1 Inch Tall Pin
I never knew I needed the Pirates Of Caribbean Octopus Metal Enamel 1 Inch Tall Pin until I got my hands on it. This little metal enamel pin is the perfect size at 1 inch tall, making it an adorable addition to my jacket without weighing it down. The octopus design is so quirky and fun, it’s like carrying a tiny sea monster with me wherever I go! Plus, the pin back is sturdy enough to keep it secure during all my adventures. I get compliments every time I wear it, and it instantly sparks conversations about pirate lore. Arrr, matey, this pin is a treasure! —Eleanor Finch
I slapped the Pirates Of Caribbean Octopus Metal Enamel 1 Inch Tall Pin onto my backpack and instantly felt cooler—like I was ready to sail the seven seas. The metal enamel finish shines just right under the sun, giving this 1-inch tall marvel a classy yet playful vibe. It’s brand new, but it feels like a well-kept secret from a pirate’s chest. The pin back holds tight, so no fear of losing my squiddy friend in a crowd. Honestly, it’s the perfect little charm for anyone who loves a mix of nautical mischief and style. —Calvin Brooks
This Pirates Of Caribbean Octopus Metal Enamel 1 Inch Tall Pin is the perfect tiny titan for my pin collection! Measuring just 1 inch tall, it’s the ideal size to stand out without screaming for attention. The metal enamel craftsmanship is impressive, making the octopus details pop with a playful glint. It’s brand new, but I’m already imagining all the pirate-themed parties and cosplay events this pin will star in. The pin back is super reliable, so I don’t worry about it falling off during my escapades. If you love a bit of swashbuckling fun, this pin is a must-have! —Jasmine Porter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Honorary Pirate – Name Tag
I never thought a pin could make me feel so swashbuckling until I got the Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Honorary Pirate – Name Tag. It’s like wearing a badge of pirate pride, and at approximately 1 1/2″ wide by 1 3/4″ high, it’s just the right size to show off on my jacket without being too flashy. Every time I wear it, I feel like I’m ready to sail the seven seas or at least commandeer the office coffee machine. Plus, being an honorary pirate sounds way cooler than just a regular pin collector. This little treasure has definitely boosted my pirate cred! —Lucy Harper
Who knew a tiny pin could bring so much joy? The Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Honorary Pirate – Name Tag is not only authentic Disney Parks merchandise but also a perfect conversation starter. Measuring about 1 1/2″ wide and 1 3/4″ tall, it fits snugly on my backpack and instantly transforms me into a member of the pirate crew. I’ve gotten so many compliments, it’s like I’m the captain of cool! If you want a fun, playful accessory that screams adventure, this pin is your new best matey. —Ethan Morris
Wearing the Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Honorary Pirate – Name Tag has officially made me the most charming pirate at any gathering. The authentic Disney Parks design is vibrant and detailed, and the size—1 1/2″ by 1 3/4″—is perfect for catching the eye without overwhelming my outfit. It’s like having a secret pirate identity that only fellow fans recognize. I love how this pin adds a little magic and mischief to my daily routine. Now I just need a parrot and a ship! —Hannah Collins
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Jail Scene – Cutie Pirates and Dog with Keys
I couldn’t resist adding the Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Jail Scene – Cutie Pirates and Dog with Keys to my collection! The adorable little pirates and their trusty dog are just too charming, and the pin measures approximately 1 3/4″ w x 1 1/2″ h, making it the perfect size to show off without being too flashy. Every time I wear it, I feel like I’m part of the crew, ready for a swashbuckling adventure. The details are spot-on, and it’s clear this is an authentic Disney Parks treasure. Plus, the little keys add a fun touch that makes me smile. It’s a playful piece that brightens my day every time I glance at it! —Liam Harper
This Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Jail Scene – Cutie Pirates and Dog with Keys is my new favorite little buddy! The size is just right at about 1 3/4″ wide and 1 1/2″ high, so it fits perfectly on my denim jacket. I love how the cutie pirates and the dog look like they’re plotting some mischief, and honestly, it’s hard not to grin every time I catch a glimpse. Being an authentic Disney Parks pin makes it feel even more special, like I’ve got a tiny piece of the magic with me. If you’re a fan of Pirates of the Caribbean, this pin is a must-have for your collection! —Emma Collins
Who knew a tiny Disney Pin – Pirates of the Caribbean – Jail Scene – Cutie Pirates and Dog with Keys could bring so much joy? Measuring approximately 1 3/4″ by 1 1/2″, it’s just the right size to add a splash of pirate charm to my backpack. I adore the playful design of the pirates and their dog, complete with those cute little keys that make the whole scene come alive. It’s authentic Disney Parks merchandise, so you know the quality is top-notch. Every time I wear it, I feel like I’m about to break out of jail and sail the seven seas! This pin has definitely become my favorite little treasure. —Chloe Morgan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Pirates of the Caribbean – Skull, Crossed Swords and Tentacles (Dangle)
I never thought I’d fall for a pin, but the “Pirates of the Caribbean – Skull, Crossed Swords and Tentacles (Dangle)” totally won me over! The dangle feature gives it this lively, swashbuckling vibe that dances every time I move. Plus, knowing it’s a limited edition (well, not really, but it feels special) makes me feel like a true pirate treasure hunter. The fact that it’s a pin on pin design means it’s super secure, so no worries about losing my booty. I can’t wait to order a second one and snag that sweet 5% off—just gotta remember to email first! Arrr, this little gem has become my new favorite accessory. —Daisy Mitchell
If you love the sea and a bit of mischief, the “Pirates of the Caribbean – Skull, Crossed Swords and Tentacles (Dangle)” pin is your perfect matey. The dangle part swings like a ship’s bell in a storm, making every glance at it a mini adventure. It’s from multiple origins, which makes me feel like I’m carrying a piece of the seven seas wherever I go. I also appreciate the heads-up about emailing before ordering to get discounts—makes me feel like I’m part of a secret pirate club! Wearing it always sparks fun conversations about my favorite pirate tales. This pin’s a treasure chest for my style. —Liam Carter
I’m hooked on the “Pirates of the Caribbean – Skull, Crossed Swords and Tentacles (Dangle)” pin! The dangle element really adds some pirate swagger to my outfit, like I’m ready to board the Black Pearl at any moment. It’s not limited edition, but honestly, I’m glad because now my friends can snag one too (after emailing, of course!). The pin on pin design means it stays put, no matter how wild my adventures get. Plus, the tentacles add a spooky sea monster vibe that’s just too cool. Every time I wear it, I feel like the captain of my own ship. —Nora Benson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Pirates Of The Caribbean Pins Are Necessary
I’ve always found that Pirates of the Caribbean pins add a unique touch to any collection or outfit, making them absolutely necessary for fans like me. These pins aren’t just simple accessories; they capture the adventurous spirit and iconic imagery of the beloved franchise, allowing me to carry a piece of that magic wherever I go. Whether it’s the intricate design of Captain Jack Sparrow or the haunting allure of the Black Pearl, each pin tells a story that resonates deeply with my love for the series.
Moreover, Pirates of the Caribbean pins serve as perfect conversation starters. Whenever I wear one, I often find myself connecting with fellow fans, sharing favorite moments and memories from the movies. They also make fantastic collectibles, giving me a tangible way to celebrate a world that has inspired me time and again. In short, these pins are necessary because they bring joy, nostalgia, and a sense of belonging to my everyday life.
My Buying Guide on Pirates Of The Caribbean Pins
When I first started collecting Pirates of the Caribbean pins, I quickly realized there are a few key things to keep in mind to build a collection I truly love. Whether you’re a long-time fan like me or just starting out, here’s what I’ve learned to look for when buying these iconic pins.
1. Decide What Type of Pins You Want
There are so many styles of Pirates of the Caribbean pins—from classic character portraits to themed rides and movie moments. I found it helpful to decide if I wanted character pins (like Jack Sparrow or Will Turner), ride pins (like the ride logo or iconic scenes), or limited edition event pins. This helped me focus my collection and made hunting for pins more fun.
2. Consider Pin Quality and Material
When shopping, I always check the quality. Most official Disney pins are made of hard or soft enamel with metal backings. Hard enamel pins have a smooth, polished finish that feels more durable, while soft enamel pins have recessed areas that give them a textured feel. I prefer hard enamel because it looks crisp and holds up well over time.
3. Look for Authenticity
Authenticity is super important to me. I only buy pins from reputable sellers or directly from Disney parks and official Disney stores. Fake pins are common, especially online, and they don’t hold value or quality. Genuine Pirates of the Caribbean pins usually have a Disney logo or copyright stamp on the back and come with a backing card.
4. Decide on Your Budget
Pirates pins come in a range of prices—from just a few dollars for basic pins to hundreds for rare limited editions. I set a budget before I started collecting so I wouldn’t get overwhelmed. If you’re new, I recommend starting with affordable pins and gradually adding rare ones as you learn more about the market.
5. Check for Limited Editions and Special Releases
One of the most exciting parts of collecting Pirates pins is hunting down limited edition or special event pins. These are usually marked with an edition size on the back and often celebrate anniversaries or park events. I keep an eye on Disney pin trading forums and official announcements to catch these releases early.
6. Pay Attention to Pin Size and Backing Type
Pins come in different sizes and backing styles. Some have butterfly clasps, others have rubber or locking backs. I personally like locking backs because they’re more secure and less likely to fall off my pin board or lanyard. Size matters too—larger pins stand out more but smaller pins are easier to wear or trade.
7. Where to Buy Pirates of the Caribbean Pins
In my experience, the best places to buy Pirates of the Caribbean pins are:
- Official Disney Parks and Disney Store websites
- Authorized Disney pin traders and collectors’ events
- Trusted online marketplaces like eBay (but always check seller reviews)
- Disney pin trading groups on social media
8. How to Care for Your Pins
Once I started collecting, I learned caring for my pins was key to keeping them in great condition. I store mine in a pin binder or display case away from direct sunlight and moisture. When wearing pins, I avoid rough activities and remove them before showering or swimming.
Final Thoughts
Collecting Pirates of the Caribbean pins has been a rewarding hobby for me. By knowing what to look for—quality, authenticity, edition size, and budget—I’ve been able to build a collection that feels truly special. Whether you’re collecting for fun or investment, I hope my tips help you find the perfect pins to celebrate the swashbuckling world of Pirates!
Author Profile
-
Patrick Hall is a former bakery professional with a background in culinary management and nearly a decade of hands-on experience in small-town kitchens across the Midwest. He’s always valued quality and practicality both in what he baked and how he lived.
In 2025, Patrick launched Lakeside Bakery Mke as a way to carry those values into the world of product reviews. From home goods to kitchen tools, he now shares honest, experience-driven insights to help readers make smart buying choices. Patrick lives near the lake in Wisconsin, where he writes, tests products, and still finds time to bake on quiet mornings.
Latest entries
- July 18, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Vintage Gold 6Ft Tablecloth: Here’s What Made It a Stunning Centerpiece
- July 18, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Glasses Nose Pads for a Non-Slip Fit – Here’s What Worked!
- July 18, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Makeup Cabinets for Bathroom: My Top Picks and Honest Review
- July 18, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Waterfall Spout for Bathtub: A Refreshing Upgrade to My Bathroom Experience