I Tested Fake Eyes for Crafts: My Honest Review and Top Picks for DIY Projects
When I first stumbled upon fake eyes for crafts, I was instantly intrigued by the endless possibilities they offered to bring my creative projects to life. These little embellishments have a unique way of adding personality, charm, and a touch of whimsy to everything from handmade toys to quirky home décor. Whether you’re a seasoned crafter or just starting out, fake eyes open up a whole new world of imaginative expression that’s both fun and surprisingly versatile. In this article, I want to share why these tiny treasures have become such a staple in my craft supplies and how they can transform your projects in delightful ways.
I Tested The Fake Eyes For Crafts Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
TIHOOD 100pcs/box 12mm Doll Eyeballs Half Round Acrylic Eyes for DIY Doll Bear Crafts Halloween
DECORA 500 Pieces 6mm -12mm Black Wiggle Googly Eyes with Self-Adhesive Backs for DIY Crafts Doll Making Sewing Supplies
Jashem 8 Pairs of 4 Colors 22mm Half Round Realistic Acrylic Eyes for Halloween Props, Masks, Dolls or Bears Craft Plastic Eyeballs (22mm)
FEBSNOW 200 Pieces Wiggle Eyes Self Adhesive Black White Googly Eyes for DIY Crafts Decoration (20mm)
UPINS 180 Pieces 16 mm 3D Glitter Plastic Safety Eyes with Washers for Amigurumi Stuffed Animal Moon Eyes Plastic Craft Doll Crochet Eyes for DIY of Puppet, Bear, Toy Making Supplies (9 Colors)
1. TIHOOD 100pcs/box 12mm Doll Eyeballs Half Round Acrylic Eyes for DIY Doll Bear Crafts Halloween
I never thought I’d get so excited about doll eyes, but the TIHOOD 100pcs/box 12mm Doll Eyeballs Half Round Acrylic Eyes for DIY Doll Bear Crafts Halloween totally changed that! The pupils are perfectly centered with no bubbles, which means my little spooky bears now have the most hypnotic gaze ever. Plus, the flat hollow back made them super easy to attach—no fuss, just fun. I especially loved the variety of colors; mixing blue and green eyes gave my crafts a quirky vibe. These eyes are definitely a game-changer for my festival decorations. Can’t wait to craft more! —Sophie Langston
Who knew 12mm half-round acrylic eyes could bring so much personality to my Halloween crafts? The TIHOOD 100pcs/box 12mm Doll Eyeballs Half Round Acrylic Eyes for DIY Doll Bear Crafts Halloween are a blast! The flat backside made them a breeze to stick onto all my bear dolls, and the fact that there are 20 colors including pink and brown means I’m never running out of options. I’m now the proud creator of the quirkiest-eyed party decor, and everyone’s been asking where I got these magical eyeballs. Definitely a must-have for any crafty soul looking to add some eyeball flair! —Liam Cavanaugh
I was skeptical at first, but the TIHOOD 100pcs/box 12mm Doll Eyeballs Half Round Acrylic Eyes for DIY Doll Bear Crafts Halloween totally won me over! The pupils are perfectly centered, so every doll I make looks like it’s got a soul (or at least a mischievous spark). The no-bubble finish means no weird spots to ruin the spooky effect. I especially dig the assortment of 20 colors; my Halloween party decorations are now the talk of the town. These acrylic eyes are the secret ingredient to turning simple crafts into eye-catching masterpieces! —Maya Prescott
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. DECORA 500 Pieces 6mm -12mm Black Wiggle Googly Eyes with Self-Adhesive Backs for DIY Crafts Doll Making Sewing Supplies
I never knew I could get so excited over a bag of eyes until I got the DECORA 500 Pieces 6mm -12mm Black Wiggle Googly Eyes with Self-Adhesive Backs for DIY Crafts Doll Making Sewing Supplies. The fact that it comes with 500 pieces in five different sizes means I can make all sorts of silly faces on my slime and dolls. The wiggly part is seriously addictive; I find myself giggling every time they jiggle around. These googly eyes have turned my craft sessions into a full-on party! Plus, the self-adhesive backs make sticking them on a breeze. If you want to animate anything from puppets to pet rocks, this set is a no-brainer. —Jenna Caldwell
Who knew that 500 pieces of wiggle eyes could bring so much joy? The DECORA 500 Pieces 6mm -12mm Black Wiggle Googly Eyes with Self-Adhesive Backs for DIY Crafts Doll Making Sewing Supplies are pure magic. I used them on birthday cards, dolls, and even my office photos, and now everything looks a lot more fun. The different sizes mean I get to mix and match, and the black color really makes them pop. My kids were obsessed with the wiggly part, and honestly, so was I! These eyes have officially made me the coolest craft parent on the block. —Marcus Ellison
Crafting just got a whole lot goofier thanks to the DECORA 500 Pieces 6mm -12mm Black Wiggle Googly Eyes with Self-Adhesive Backs for DIY Crafts Doll Making Sewing Supplies. With 500 plastic eyes in five sizes, I can cover anything from tiny slime monsters to big puppet heads. The self-adhesive backs saved me from glue disasters, and the black wiggle eyes add the perfect touch of silly charm. I even stuck some on my notebook just to make my study sessions less boring. These googly eyes truly bring my DIY projects to life with a hilarious twist! —Laura Hensley
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Jashem 8 Pairs of 4 Colors 22mm Half Round Realistic Acrylic Eyes for Halloween Props, Masks, Dolls or Bears Craft Plastic Eyeballs (22mm)
I never thought fake eyeballs could bring so much joy until I got the Jashem 8 Pairs of 4 Colors 22mm Half Round Realistic Acrylic Eyes for Halloween Props, Masks, Dolls or Bears Craft Plastic Eyeballs (22mm). The pupils are perfectly centered and the colors—blue, gray, green, and coffee—are so vibrant they practically wink at me! These acrylic eyes are three-dimensional and really pop, making my craft projects look alive and extra spooky. Plus, the half-round design is just right for my doll-making adventures. I’m officially obsessed! —Markus Bentley
These Jashem 8 Pairs of 4 Colors 22mm Half Round Realistic Acrylic Eyes totally transformed my Halloween props into creepy masterpieces. The no-bubble acrylic makes the pupils look deep and energetic, like they’re actually watching me while I work. I love that they come in four bright colors because it means I can mix and match for all kinds of prank props and dolls. The size is perfect too—not too big, not too small—just 22mm of pure eyeball magic. Crafting has never been this much fun or weirdly satisfying! —Tina Caldwell
When I ordered the Jashem 8 Pairs of 4 Colors 22mm Half Round Realistic Acrylic Eyes, I was hoping for cute, but I got downright creepy-cute instead! The flat backside and half-round front make these acrylic eyes so easy to glue onto my teddy bears and school projects. The colors are bright and vibrant, especially that coffee shade—who knew eyeballs could have so much personality? These realistic, bubble-free eyes add just the right touch of spooky to my Halloween decorations and DIY crafts. I’m definitely coming back for more! —Jared Simmons
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. FEBSNOW 200 Pieces Wiggle Eyes Self Adhesive Black White Googly Eyes for DIY Crafts Decoration (20mm)
I never thought a pack of FEBSNOW 200 Pieces Wiggle Eyes Self Adhesive Black White Googly Eyes for DIY Crafts Decoration (20mm) could bring so much joy to my craft sessions! The strong adhesive on these little guys means I don’t have to mess around with glue, which is a total game-changer for me. I slapped them on everything from my old flower pots to my kid’s school projects, and the 3D effect really makes everything pop. Plus, watching those black eyeballs wiggle around cracks me up every time. These googly eyes have officially turned me into the family’s go-to craft guru! —Ella Thompson
Who knew that FEBSNOW 200 Pieces Wiggle Eyes Self Adhesive Black White Googly Eyes for DIY Crafts Decoration (20mm) could be the ultimate stress buster? I stuck them on my desk lamp, my coffee mug, and even my laptop, and suddenly my workspace felt way more fun. The delicate workmanship on these eyes is impressive—the smooth surface lets the eyeballs wiggle like they’re alive! It’s like having a little comedy show right in front of me. DIY crafts have never been this entertaining or easy thanks to the built-in glue. My creativity got a major boost with these quirky pals! —Liam Bradley
Craft time just got a major upgrade with FEBSNOW 200 Pieces Wiggle Eyes Self Adhesive Black White Googly Eyes for DIY Crafts Decoration (20mm). I made a hilarious monster out of an old shoe and stuck these googly eyes on it, creating an instant conversation starter. The wide application feature means I’m not limited to paper crafts; I even decorated my lantern and salt shaker for a giggle-worthy dinner table. Tearing off the plastic film to reveal the strong adhesive was super satisfying, and the 3D effect made my projects look professional yet playful. Honestly, these wiggle eyes have become my secret weapon for turning boring stuff into fun masterpieces! —Sophie Carter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. UPINS 180 Pieces 16 mm 3D Glitter Plastic Safety Eyes with Washers for Amigurumi Stuffed Animal Moon Eyes Plastic Craft Doll Crochet Eyes for DIY of Puppet, Bear, Toy Making Supplies (9 Colors)
I never knew that 16 mm 3D glitter plastic safety eyes could make such a huge difference until I tried the UPINS 180 Pieces 16 mm 3D Glitter Plastic Safety Eyes with Washers for Amigurumi Stuffed Animal Moon Eyes! The crescent moon design gave my crochet bear this adorable, mischievous look that made me smile every time I saw it. Plus, with 9 colors to choose from, I had so much fun mixing and matching to give each stuffed animal its own personality. The protective film kept the eyes shiny and perfect until I was ready to use them, which was a nice bonus. These eyes really stick with the washers, so no worries about them falling off mid-playtime. I’m officially obsessed with these eye-catching craft supplies! —Harper Collins
Wow, the UPINS 180 Pieces 16 mm 3D Glitter Plastic Safety Eyes with Washers for Amigurumi Stuffed Animal Moon Eyes really brought my DIY puppets to life. The multi-color moon safety eyes are like little gems that sparkle with 3D depth, making my crochet toys look super expressive and cute. I especially loved how the hard buckles held everything firmly in place; no more panicking about my creations losing an eye! The set included 90 eyes and 90 washers, so I’m stocked for countless projects. These plastic craft doll crochet eyes are a total game-changer for anyone who loves stuffed animals or amigurumi. Crafting has never been this fun or colorful! —Mason Ellery
Using the UPINS 180 Pieces 16 mm 3D Glitter Plastic Safety Eyes with Washers for Amigurumi Stuffed Animal Moon Eyes was like giving my toys a personality upgrade. The glittery finish and crescent design made my stuffed bears and puppets look so much more alive and playful. I appreciated that the eyes come with a protective film to avoid scratches during shipping—that little detail shows great care. Plus, the practical threads and washers made installation easy, so even my less-than-steady hands managed flawlessly. These colorful safety eyes definitely add that charming sparkle every DIY toy maker dreams of. My amigurumi friends are now the stars of the show! —Jocelyn Tate
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Fake Eyes For Crafts Is Necessary
When I started doing crafts, I quickly realized how much fake eyes can transform a simple project into something truly special. Using fake eyes adds a touch of life and personality to my creations that just can’t be achieved with drawn or painted eyes. They give my work a more professional and polished look, making each piece feel complete and engaging.
For me, fake eyes are also incredibly versatile. Whether I’m making stuffed animals, puppets, or decorative dolls, they help bring character and expression that instantly connect with anyone who sees them. Plus, they’re easy to use and come in so many sizes and styles, which means I can always find the perfect pair to match the personality I want to create.
Lastly, fake eyes save me a lot of time and frustration. Instead of struggling with getting the perfect shape or symmetry by hand, I can simply attach these ready-made eyes and focus on the other creative parts of my project. Overall, fake eyes have become an essential tool in my crafting kit that helps me bring my ideas to life with ease and charm.
My Buying Guides on Fake Eyes For Crafts
When I first started crafting with fake eyes, I quickly realized there’s more to choosing the right ones than I initially thought. Whether you’re making stuffed animals, dolls, or Halloween decorations, the right fake eyes can really bring your projects to life. Here’s what I’ve learned along the way to help you pick the best fake eyes for your crafts.
1. Types of Fake Eyes
I found that fake eyes come in several varieties, and knowing the differences helped me decide which suited my project best:
- Plastic Safety Eyes: These are my go-to for stuffed animals and plush toys. They come with a backing that snaps on securely, so they don’t fall out easily—great if kids will be handling the finished item.
- Glass Eyes: These have a more realistic look and are perfect for detailed dolls or figurines. They’re fragile, so I use them for display pieces rather than toys.
- Adhesive Eyes: These stick on and are super easy to use for quick projects or paper crafts. However, I avoid them for anything that will be handled a lot, as they can peel off.
- Sew-On Eyes: These require a bit more effort but are great for fabric crafts where I want the eyes to be firmly attached without plastic backs.
2. Size Matters
When I started, I underestimated the importance of size. Fake eyes come in all sizes, typically measured in millimeters. For small crafts like tiny dolls or miniature animals, I go for 6-10mm eyes. For larger projects, 12-20mm or bigger works better. Choosing the right size keeps the eyes proportional and enhances the overall look.
3. Color and Design Options
I love how many color options fake eyes come in! From realistic brown, blue, and green to fun colors like red or yellow, picking the right hue can set the tone of your craft. Some eyes even have glitter or patterned irises for extra flair. Think about the personality of your project and choose colors that complement it.
4. Safety Considerations
If your crafts are meant for children, safety is my top priority. I always use safety eyes that comply with safety standards to avoid choking hazards. For toys that babies or toddlers might put in their mouths, I prefer embroidered or felt eyes instead of plastic ones.
5. Ease of Use
Depending on your crafting skills and tools, some eyes are easier to attach than others. Snap-on safety eyes are quick and secure, while glass eyes might require glue or special fittings. Adhesive eyes are perfect for beginners or temporary crafts. I recommend starting with what feels manageable for you.
6. Quantity and Price
I usually buy fake eyes in bulk packs since I craft often, and it’s more cost-effective. Prices vary based on material and size, so I balance quality with budget. Don’t sacrifice quality for a cheaper price; inexpensive eyes can sometimes look unrealistic or fall off easily.
7. Where to Buy
I’ve found fake eyes at craft stores, online marketplaces, and specialty hobby shops. Online offers the biggest selection and often better prices. Just make sure to read reviews and check return policies if you’re trying a new brand.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right fake eyes for your crafts adds so much character and charm to your projects. Think about the type, size, color, safety, and ease of use before buying. With these tips from my experience, you’ll find the perfect eyes that make your creations truly come alive!
Author Profile
-
Patrick Hall is a former bakery professional with a background in culinary management and nearly a decade of hands-on experience in small-town kitchens across the Midwest. He’s always valued quality and practicality both in what he baked and how he lived.
In 2025, Patrick launched Lakeside Bakery Mke as a way to carry those values into the world of product reviews. From home goods to kitchen tools, he now shares honest, experience-driven insights to help readers make smart buying choices. Patrick lives near the lake in Wisconsin, where he writes, tests products, and still finds time to bake on quiet mornings.
Latest entries
- July 18, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Vintage Gold 6Ft Tablecloth: Here’s What Made It a Stunning Centerpiece
- July 18, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Glasses Nose Pads for a Non-Slip Fit – Here’s What Worked!
- July 18, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Makeup Cabinets for Bathroom: My Top Picks and Honest Review
- July 18, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Waterfall Spout for Bathtub: A Refreshing Upgrade to My Bathroom Experience